Moving from New York to Austin, Texas: What $3,000 a Month Actually Buys in 2026
Moving from New York to Austin, Texas: What $3,000 a Month Actually Buys in 2026
Quick Answer: If you are moving from New York to Austin, Texas, $3,000 a month all in, meaning principal, interest, taxes, and insurance, puts you around a $400,000 home in South Austin as of July 2026. In Manhattan, that same money rents a one bedroom you will never own. Texas property taxes are higher than what you are used to, but zero state income tax usually more than covers the difference.
By Brandon Holley, Broker/Owner, Holley Homes Realty
If you would rather watch than read, the full video is right above.
Why are so many New Yorkers moving to Texas right now?
You are not imagining this. Texas is the number one state in the country for people moving in, and New York is one of the top three states sending them.
The reason is simple, and it comes down to what a dollar buys. As of July 2026, the median one bedroom apartment in Manhattan rents for around $4,393 a month. That is rent. At the end of the year you own nothing.
I work with these buyers every week, from Manhattan, from Brooklyn, and from just across the river in New Jersey. It is the same conversation every time, so here is the honest version of it.
What does $3,000 a month buy in South Austin?
As of July 2026, a 30 year fixed mortgage is running around 6.46%. Take that rate, a standard down payment, and add Texas property taxes and homeowners insurance, and $3,000 a month all in puts you right around a $400,000 home here in South Austin. That is a three or four bedroom house with a yard.
Where you point that $400,000 changes what you get. Here is how it breaks down across the areas I actually work.
Area | Median sale price (June 2026) | What your $400,000 does |
|---|---|---|
South Austin, 78748 | $385,000 | Lands you mid market, three to four bedrooms, closest to the city |
Buda, 78610 | About $338,000 | Buys above the local median, more house, easy I-35 access |
Kyle, 78640 | About $301,000 | Buys well above median, newer construction, bigger lot |
Bastrop, 78602 | About $412,000 | Close to a full median home, and it is a buyer market |
A quick note on 78748, the heart of South Austin around Manchaca Road and Slaughter Lane. That market is fast, with homes selling in about 18 days. If that is where you want to be, you need your financing lined up and you need to be ready to move the week a house hits.
Now compare that to what you left. Three to four thousand dollars a month was rent on a one bedroom. Here it is your mortgage on a house you own, with a yard, in a good school district.
The honest catch: what do Texas property taxes and insurance really cost?
Here is the part most agents skip because it is not the fun part. Texas property taxes are high and there is no way around it.
In the Austin area you are generally looking at an effective rate somewhere around 1.8 to 2% of the home's value per year. In some brand new master planned communities that have a MUD or a PID, which is a special taxing district that pays for the roads and amenities, that combined rate can climb to 2.5 or even 3%. Homeowners insurance is not cheap either. The statewide average in 2026 is running around $3,800 a year.
That is exactly why $3,000 a month buys around $400,000 here. In a low tax state that same payment might stretch to a $450,000 home. In Texas, the taxes and insurance pull it back. A lot of relocation videos show you the low sticker price and go quiet on the tax bill. I would rather you see the real number.
So if you fall in love with a brand new home in a master planned community, always ask what the total tax rate is, including any MUD or PID. That is the one number that quietly changes your monthly payment, and it is the first thing I check for every single client. My MUD and PID checklist walks through how to read it before you sign anything.
What is the number that actually makes this move work?
New York state income tax runs from 4% all the way up to 10.9%. If you live in New York City, you pay a city income tax on top of that, close to another 3.9%. A household earning around $150,000 in the city can pay well over $12,000 a year in state and city income tax combined.
Texas has none of that. Zero state income tax, zero city income tax. Before you have talked about a single house, moving from New York to Texas is like handing yourself a raise of $10,000, $12,000, sometimes even $15,000 a year in taxes you no longer pay.
Here is the key. That raise often covers the higher property tax you were just worried about. It is the inversion most people get backwards. They come in nervous about the property tax, and when you run the whole picture, the income tax you stop paying usually wins.
What about New Jersey?
If you are coming from New Jersey, your situation is even more lopsided. New Jersey has the highest property taxes in the country, with an average bill over $9,000 a year, plus a state income tax on top of it.
So coming to Texas, you drop the income tax completely, and our property taxes, as high as they are, will not shock you the way they shock a New Yorker. You have already seen worse.
Which Central Texas town is right for you?
Who this fits best: If you want the most house for your $3,000 a month, look at Kyle or Buda along the I-35 corridor. Your money buys well above the local median in Hays CISD, and you are still an easy drive into Austin. If you want to be in the core of South Austin, closer to the city and to Austin Bergstrom, 78748 is your spot, as long as you can move fast. If you want negotiating room and a little more land, look at Bastrop out along Highway 71 near the Colorado River. It is a buyer market right now, which means you have leverage you have not had in New York in years.
Who should look elsewhere: If walkability and the subway are non negotiable for you, be honest about that before you buy. South Austin is not Manhattan and I am not going to tell you it is. You will miss the food, the trains, and being able to walk everywhere. If that trade is a dealbreaker, a lease here first is a smarter move than a purchase.
What my Brooklyn buyers keep telling me
I worked with a couple from Brooklyn a few months back, and the thing they said to me over and over is that they could not believe how much space they got for the price. They walked into a house here, a real house with a yard, a garage, and an extra room for an office, and the number on it was less than what they were paying to rent a one bedroom back home. It genuinely stopped them in their tracks.
That reaction is the whole thing. It is not that South Austin is trying to be New York. It is that you get to trade a small expensive footprint for room to actually live, space for your kids, a yard for your dog, and an office so you are not working from the kitchen table.
If you would like to see a related video on this topic, the one above (or below) is a great next watch. It compares Kyle, Buda, and Bastrop side by side so you can narrow down the town before you narrow down the house.
Want the full picture before you start touring? My free Central Texas Relocation Guide walks through every one of these neighborhoods, the tax math, and a realistic relocation timeline.
One honest note before I let you go. Every number here is real and current, but your number will be your own. What you pay each month depends on your down payment, your loan, and the exact tax rate of the neighborhood you pick, and what you keep depends on your income and how you file, so always check the tax details with your CPA. Use these numbers for the big picture, because the big picture on moving from New York to Austin, Texas is very real, then let's run your actual situation together.
FAQ
How much house does $3,000 a month buy in Austin, Texas? As of July 2026, with a 30 year fixed around 6.46% and a standard down payment, $3,000 a month all in, meaning principal, interest, taxes, and insurance, puts you around a $400,000 home in South Austin. In Kyle or Buda that same budget buys well above the local median.
Are Texas property taxes really that high? Yes. In the Austin area the effective rate generally runs about 1.8 to 2% of the home's value per year. In newer master planned communities with a MUD or PID, the combined rate can reach 2.5 to 3%. Always ask for the total rate, including special districts, before you write an offer.
Does no state income tax in Texas make up for the property taxes? For most of the New Yorkers I work with, yes. New York state income tax runs 4% to 10.9%, and New York City adds close to another 3.9%. A household around $150,000 can pay over $12,000 a year combined. Texas charges zero, and that savings usually covers the higher property tax.
Is South Austin or Kyle better for someone moving from New York? It depends on what you want back. South Austin, especially 78748, keeps you closest to the city but moves fast, with homes selling in about 18 days. Kyle and Buda give you more square footage and newer construction for the same money, with an easy I-35 drive into Austin.
What is a MUD or PID tax in Central Texas? A MUD or PID is a special taxing district common in newer master planned communities that pays for roads and amenities. Its rate stacks on top of your county rate and can push your combined rate to 2.5 or 3%. It quietly changes your monthly payment, so ask for the total rate up front.
How much is homeowners insurance in Texas? The statewide average in 2026 is running around $3,800 a year. That is meaningfully higher than many buyers expect, and along with property taxes it is the reason $3,000 a month buys around $400,000 here instead of the $450,000 it might buy in a lower tax state.
About the Author
Brandon Holley is the Broker and Owner of Holley Homes Realty in Austin, Texas. He works with first-time homebuyers, new construction clients, and relocation buyers moving to Central Texas from across the country. Brandon hosts a recurring segment on American Dream TV and runs the YouTube channel Your Austin Home Guide, where he breaks down communities, builders, and neighborhoods across Austin, Buda, Kyle, Bastrop, and the surrounding suburbs.
Have a question or thinking about a move to Central Texas? Reach out anytime.
SEARCH HOMES
Search new construction: New Home Buddy
Search the MLS: Unlock MLS
WORK WITH BRANDON
Brandon Holley — Broker/Owner, Holley Homes Realty
Serving South Austin, Kyle, Buda & Bastrop
512.487.9242 | brandon@holleyhomesrealty.com
Grab some time: Calendar
About Brandon: Meet Me
Subscribe: YouTube
I understand now may not be the right time and I never want to be pushy, just know that I am here if you have questions, would like to start planning, or need anything.
